The situation starts when you realise 'Oh, it's time I lost some weight!' Being perfectly aware of the calorie load that can be chopped off simply by abstaining from chocolate, you decide 'OK! No more chocolate, starting TOMORROW!' (one always embarks on such a difficult quest tomorrow, and never at the instant at which one commits to the decision) . So far so good.. cutting out your main calorie source, you begin to lose weight and feel happier about yourself. This is the balancing feedback loop, no pain no gain - there never was a truer phrase. Yes, no chocolate is one of the worst kinds of pain for the chocaholic.
There's just one problem - after a while you begin to wonder about how chocolate tasted back when you used to eat it. You drool at the sight of anyone eating a chocolate bar, you begin to find difficulty in restraining yourself every time you open the fridge, or every time you pass in front of a shop packed with chocolate goodies. If that wasn't enough, you KNOW you've been truly defeated when you begin to dream about eating chocolate in your sleep! You wake up the next day and the FIRST thing you do is march right out the house and come back with 4 bars of chocolate. You find a dark corner inside your house, curl up and munch away with glee. You are reacquainted with the joy that is chocolate, and now you find it hard to stop. Your weight goes up again and you are back to where you started. This is the reinforcing loop titled 'chocolate love affair', and as with all love affairs, one that is very hard to stop.. once you are stuck in this loop it is often a while before you gain enough weight to signal 'stop eating chocolate' again.
It is obvious that cutting out chocolate from one's diet is not the answer to losing weight. This is the inadequacy of the approach in this example. I suppose that putting in an exercise loop somewhere in the causal loop diagram below would serve to balance out the unintended consequences that accompany complete abstinence from chocolate. Other variables I know contribute to this problem are lack of time in which to exercise as well as the pressure of other duties such as school or work that keep one stuck at a desk - chocolate is a cheerful sight to the overworked student.
I have kept the diagram simple as requested, however I really think there is potential for it to expand further. All this talk about chocolate has got me wondering.. surely one little piece won't hurt.. or would it?!

Justine, I have absolutely understood that you are a true chocoholic, no doubt about it! I truly sympathize and so I feel it in my duty to write a few words of empathy. First things first, I see no misconceptions in your CLD. It is very clear and makes perfect sense to me. So, here are a few suggestions that follow your attempted solutions. Chocolate abstinence could be linked with regular exercise, which in turn reduces calorie intake, reduces weight, makes you feel better, and reduces chocolate craving and the urge of chocolate binging. Another suggestion could be to enrol in weekly hypnosis sessions that could stop chocolate craving. However, I suggest that you take this into consideration only after the termination of the SERM course!!! :) The last unintended consequence I would like to share is that increasing calorie intake not only increases weight but could cause serious health problems which in turn could lead to a forced medical abstinence. Try to choose ‘good chocolate’ and you’ll be able to eat it forever! Avoid chocolate containing sugar and fat in the form of chocolate butter. When buying chocolate try to read the label and choose those who have high chocolate solids and beneficial cocoa butter. Avoid those that have Hydrogenated Vegetable Oils (HVO’s) and flavoured fondants and pralines! Hopefully this will help you reshape your CLD with two new variables: Namely GOOD CHOCOLATE and BAD CHOCOLATE, where the former will provide satisfactory feelings when taken, whilst the latter will lead to all the mentioned unintended consequences!!!
ReplyDeleteBoth Justine's CLD and Shawn's comment are awesome!!! After a weekend working with CLDs, graphs and blogs, what I need is some good chocolate, no matter the unintended consequences :)
ReplyDeleteWoe for the chocoholics and the tragic CLDs we must endure...(did I say we?)
ReplyDelete